My MIL found out about Madison Street Beauty on the Today show and immediately thought of me. She told me to pick out a few that I was interested in and that she would get them for me as a birthday present. So, naturally, I immediately scoured the web in search of swatches. Turns out, there aren't really any out there. When I got my polishes in the mail and started testing them out, I decided "Hey, I should really put these on my neglected blog in case other people are curious about this brand too!" And here we are! If you are interested in purchasing any of the polishes shown below, take a look around Madison Street Beauty's ETSY page.
Ok, here we go!
First, I want to comment on how fantastic the shipping and customer service was. My MIL made a typo on the zip code and not even a few hours later, customer service contacted her to clear it up. She placed the order on a Friday and that Monday I had a surprise waiting in my mailbox! The polishes came wrapped up in this little box:
They are the same size as the mini OPI polishes.
On to the polish! I want to start with Coral Sherbert. This was the polish I was most looking forward to when I picked out my colors. I seem to hoard corals and this shimmery baby needed a home in my collection. This polish is described as an "opaque and shimmery coral-pink." This is the photo used on their site:
In real life the polish is much lighter and more of a rose than a coral. I definitely wouldn't have called it opaque, either.
Even after three coats I could see my nail lines. This isn't a terrible color, it just wasn't what I was expecting. It is a good neutral polish to wear at a more conservative work atmosphere. It had a classy sheen to it without coming across as a grandma color. I was very pleased with the application (other than the 3 coats and still sheer factor). It applied smoothly and dried quickly. While I was applying, I felt like I had seen this polish recently. Then it hit me: OPI Hands Off my Kielbasa! So I dug up my bottle for a quick comparison.
That is one coat of OPI on my thumb verses 3 of Coral Sherbert. SO not exactly dupes, but I'd say cousins. The OPI is about 2 shades darker and way more opaque.
Next up is Lush Lilac. I was the most worried about this one. I figured it would be super sheer and a little temperamental, but it ended up being my favorite! They described it as an "opaque lilac with pink shimmer"
This is the site's photo:
I think this one looks way better in real life!
This is 2 coats. It was less greyed out in real life. I didn't have anything like this in my collection. The first similar polish to come to mind was OPI Significant Other Color, but they are waaaaayyyy different.
Lush Lilac is much more Opaque and more of a blue-toned purple. Again the formula was pretty good but I did have some bubbling on my index finger.
Next up, Pacific Cobalt. I'm always on the never ending search of navy polishes that don't end up looking black. This one seems like a good. shimmery candidate and it did not disappoint. It is describes as an "opaque navy blue with deep purple shimmer." Here is the site's image:
And real life:
This had such a lovely, dusty/teslish lean to it! I was really not expecting that when I applied the second coat.
Just for comparison purposes:
While I was waiting for this to dry I decided to go get a drink and tripped on my way to the kitchen. A moment of silence for my first go round.
And for comparison I dug into my blue vault lol
(Left to right: OPI I saw, you saw, we saw, Warsaw, OPI Eurso Euro, Madison Street Beauty Pacific Cobalt, OPI Into the Night, and Orly La Playa)
I think it leaned closest to Into the Night (thumb).
Still totally different though.
Last we have Island Cove. This is the polish that I instantly clicked on when I went to their web store. I'm such a sucker for these aqua/teal colors. It is describes as a "shimmering teal." This one is fairly true to the site's image:
Real life:
How beautiful is this one! It has just enough metalic-ness to make it glow but not so much to make it frosty. I love polishes like these! Again, formula was good. This was 2 coats.
Comparisons (left to right: OPI Fly, Zoya Zuza, ORLY Bailamos, MSB Island Cove, and Essie Beach Bum Blu)
Compared to ORLY:
Shade wise, these are fairly spot on, but the Orly polish (thumb) has more of a glittery shimmer unlike Island Cove which is more metallic. They are pretty close, though.Compared to Essie:
These look like dupes in the picture, but in real life Essie was way froster and more blue than aqua.
Overall I was very pleased with my polishes! I was very worried going in because I have no experience buying Indie polishes and there was little to no info about these polishes online. So if you are a curious consumer wondering if these polishes are worth buying, I vote yes! This experience really has me itching to try out more indies! Leave a comment for suggestions of a brand you would recommend!